Showing posts with label Big Ten. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Big Ten. Show all posts

Saturday, September 27, 2008

Todays' Picks

Ok first week of the conference race and let me first again state my complete displeasure of the fact that each team only plays 8 opponents out of a possible ten. I will share this week what an unfair advantage that is for a couple of teams this season. I know that some years some teams will always have the better home schedule etc. But by not playing the same 2 teams for a two year period you can have a big advantage.

One example, for 2009 and 2010, Michigan State is expected to be a competitive team in the conference. They do NOT play Ohio State! This means they skate by having to play a perennial power AND they skip Pryor in probably his peak years as a college QB before moving on to the NFL. But I am getting ahead of myself

This week:

Michigan State plays Indiana and I think we may see in a week or two if Indiana is indeed the weakest team in the conference. Lewis is a strong QB but one has to believe that the Spartans will chew up the Hoosier defense with a lot of running.

I am not sold on either Iowa or NU but I give the nod to the Hawkeyes since it is their home field and they had at least one tough test against an improving Pitt team.

Minnesota is clearly a better team than last year but they are not this years version of the 2007 Illini...they are at least a year away. The Buckeyes with Wells win this one at home!

Michigan Wisconsin. Michigan loses it's first Big Ten home opener in 23 years UNLESS the defense holds the Badgers to under 21. Michigan MIGHT pull off one long drive, one Barnum Bailey TD with McGuffie front and center and MAYBE a short field TD based on a defensive led turnover....THAT'S best case. If UM plays anywhere nearly as sloppy here as they did at ND or as flat as they did against Miami it will be embarrassing. I think Badgers win by 10 or less

Purdue vs Notre Dame. I am not impressed with Notre Dame despite what they did to Michigan. Their running game is weak, but Clausen has gotten better. If this is a high scoring game I give it to Purdue, lower scoring game allows the Domers to sneak a win. I hate Notre Dame and I am a Big Ten fan so this one I call for Purdue!

Yes it is a White Out at State College,PA which along with Wisconsin creates the craziest home advantage in the conference. We will begin to see how good Penn State is tonight if they win by more than a TD. The Illini are good but not great...although if they pull this upset on the road..well I have to rethink that statement. I think the winner of this game challenges OSU for the title..wow this early in the season a big game for sure!

Enjoy its a great day for football!

Tuesday, September 23, 2008

It's not the Big One Little Ten afterall! Predictions

Ok, the Big Ten looks like it might be a bit closer than I originally had discussed in the pre season. There are several reasons for this change

1) Ohio State looks mortal between Beanie not being 100% and the QB situation being up in the air.

2) Wisconsin, Penn State and Michigan State are playing better than expected at least by me. It's really hard to know how good Penn State is, however I think the winner of the Penn State Illini game Saturday is in the hunt for sure.

So here are my predictions and yes it's much easier to make these now vs before the first game of the season. However with the gained knowledge my self expectations are much higher. I would expect that my total wins differential should be less than 11 meaning less than 1 per team plus or minus. Guessing a team will go 3-5 and they go 5-3 is just as bad as guessing 5-3 and they go 2-5.

I've also posted my predictions within an Excel workbook so you can enter yours and see how you compare with mine and friends of yours at the end of the season. You can get that by visiting the Downloads page on the website or just click here .

If you are really brave you can go public with your pics either by commenting here, or entering the contest on the Fansofthebig11 social network site. Go to Forums for more info there.

Ohio State 7-1
Illinois 6-2
Penn State 6-2
Wisconsin 5-3
Michigan State 5-3
Purdue 4-4
Iowa 3-5
Northwestern 3-5
Minnesota 2-6
Michigan 2-6
Indiana 1-7

I might be selling UW and MSU short but I think in both cases their QBs will be unable to rally their teams if they fall behind in tough games. Northwestern is one of the worst 4-0 teams I've seen and Minnesota, while much better than last year is still a year away from a true bowl team.

Michigan has a tough schedule and frankly is a circus act on offense and the defense is good but not great and therefore they will lose every game among the Top 5 teams in the league for sure. This season is pay back for MSU and Penn State over the Wolverines.

I would be surprised if any other team cracks the Top 5 beyond who I have listed and I will be pretty surprised if the Buckeyes lose more than 1 Big Ten game. But hey the arguing and the season begin!

Friday, September 12, 2008

5 games that matter

This week things get much more interesting in terms of the non conference schedule.

Iowa plays in state rival Iowa State a game which has often been a waterloo for Iowa. While ISU is not set to challenge for the BCS bowls, this will be a good test of whether Iowa has a chance to be a legitimate contender for a mid to higher tier bowl game. I do believe the Hawkeyes have improved and will win this game.

Michigan plays Notre Dame. The game between the 2 winningest programs in college football and also two teams that are not playing at the level that achieved those records. ND and Charlie Weis have more to lose here. They need to try and avenge the 38-0 destruction that took place last year in Ann Arbor. ND had their year of "unproven offensive players" last year.

Despite Charlie Weis crack this summer...Michigan fans are not going to make excuses. Michigan always wants to beat ND and a win would show some hope that this team can beat average Big Ten teams. As weak as ND appears to be relative to normal expectations..a win Saturday would be a boost to the Wolverines. For Notre Dame a loss here means the beginning of the end for Charlie Loudmouth. Given it's at South Bend and how weak the Michigan offense is, sad to say the Big Ten takes a loss here.

Wisconsin vs Fresno State. Well Alvridge played better last week at QB and we know the Badgers can run. Freson State has shown they are a tough team although they beat Rutgers who is really not very good this year. A win here would be a signature game for Fresno State in their effort to crash the BCS, a loss means they fight for a 2nd/3rd tier bowl spot at best. The game is at Fresno State but the Badgers should grind out a win..just hope they don't get down 2 touchdowns again.

Purdue vs Oregon. This would be a great win for the Big Ten as Oregon is rated higher and Purdue isn't even considered a Top 4 Big Ten team this season whereas Oregon certainly is within the Pac 10. The game is at Purdue and Matt Painter certainly has the experience needed for a big day. I am hoping for the upset, that Purdue shows a defense strong enough to stop Oregon from scoring 35 or more...but I think this one goes to Oregon.

Ohio State vs USC. Well Beanie isn't playing and one has to say the hopes of the Buckeyes rests on their defense keeping the Trojans out of the end zone and creating a short field for its offense via turnovers. A win at SC under these conditions would be heroic almost as much as the win over Miami a few years back for the BCS title. Given how little Pryor played last week when the game with Ohio was close..does anyone think he will get significant opportunities here? Is the risk for making mistakes too high to warrant the potential big play/series he could spark with his legs?

In summary I think we are looking at 2-3 of the big games. A 5-0 run this week would go a LONG WAY to shutting up the national media and disway my own fears about the strength of the conference.

This weak EVERYONE IN THE BIG TEN needs to be a Badger, Hawkeye, Wolverine, Boilermaker, Buckeye fan GO BIG TEN

Friday, September 5, 2008

spoiler week?

ESPN Magazine Rated Penn State Best overall Student Section as well as Most Fun, 2nd Most Creative and 4th Loudest

ESPN Magazine picked Wisconsin as the Nastiest Student Section. After visiting at the UW-UM game a few years ago I would agree

The Big Ten Averages 6.3 yards per pound of running back. That ratio is best among all conferences despite the fact the Big Ten backfields averaged 11 lbs heavier than the next nearest conference (source ESPN Magazine August 25, 2008)

Michigan has the best average finish of any Big Ten football team since 2003 (1.8 place vs. 2.0 averages for Ohio State. Iowa is 3rd at 4.2 and Wisconsin 4.8)


Spoiler Week?

On paper the Big Ten should win all 11 of their games this week, Only Penn State plays another BCS conference team meaning we’ve scheduled more cupcakes this week than last week when Illinois played Mizzou and Michigan State played Cal.

The MAC, the WAC, the Mountain West, the Sun Belt and Conference USA make up the non BCS conferences. Of these smaller conferences, the Mountain West wins a respectable 38% of the time and includes Utah and Fresno State the 2 schools that have beaten more BCS teams than any other non BCS. The performance drops off considerably with CUSA next at 18%, the WAC at 16% the MAC at 11% and finally the Sun Belt at 5%.

In terms of total games played against BCS schools, The MAC has played the most by far: 162. Then comes Conference USA- 118, then the Sun Belt at 109 followed by the WAC at 88 and the Mountain West at 73. A couple theories here. First the MAC plays a lot of Big Ten teams often including its worst teams due to proximity (lower travel costs) and desire for big pay days. Second, the WAC and Mountain West are farther away from most BCS schools other than the PAC 10 and therefore they play fewer BCS games.

Third, the Mountain West picks there spots, choosing to have better teams in their conference play BCS schools (i.e. Utah and Fresno State playing Michigan and Rutgers last week vs. sending some bottom dwellers). Of course I’d need more data to back this up. I do think the stats do back up the fact that the Big Ten schedules a weak non conference school loaded with MAC teams.

Let’s look at this week’s games and see where the Spoilers might be

Michigan State vs. Eastern Michigan. Despite Mr. Hoyer’s challenges I can’t see the Spartans losing expect a lot of Ringer. By the way that Dell kid (WR) flew under the radar in terms of national media but he had over 200 yds receiving including several very good catches for State

Michigan vs. Miami, OH. Ok despite Miami losing to Vandy last week this isn’t as easy as it sounds. Vandy turns out is a pretty good team and Michigan it turns out is not. Unlike years past where the Wolverines could grind out a win via the run…M will have to rely on the defense and avoid special teams big plays in order to make sure this is a W. But this looks like Big Ten 2-0 for these two games

Minnesota at Bowling Green. Well BG beat Pitt and Minnesota barely beat NIU. The Gophers are away and help the MAC keep their 11% winning percentage against BCS in tact. Big Ten 2 MAC 1

Illinois vs. E. Illinois. The Illini use to need these 1AA games to prop up their record..No logger. EIU is a good 1AA school but no match here…cupcake supreme

Wisconsin vs. Marshall. The Thundering Herd continues to improve. I think they are I the CUSA? I forget admittedly I can’t check the Net as I am flying home as I right this entry.
Badgers should win regardless

Ohio vs. Ohio State..Hmm even without Beanie Wells ad despite Ohio playing better one has to say this should be another Buckeye big win as they tour the intrastate pastries. Again I think Ohio is CUSA but maybe not? Feel free to correct me on these if I am wrong

Murray State at Indiana…the Hoosiers continue to feed at the dessert trough in non conference play. This schedule is embarrassing!

N. Colorado at Purdue. Wasn’t NCU the school where one punter stabbed another trying to get his job? This is the opener for the Boilermakers and should be a win

Florida International vs. Iowa. Not to be confused with Florida Atlantic…this Florida school is YEARS away from being competitive. The Hawkeyes roll to 2-0

These weeks BCS games

Northwestern by 6 over Duke. Our small bright school against the ACC’s. Our conference is infinitely better than the ACC this year and Northwestern is not a cellar dweller like Duke is. The home team and NU was shaky on offense in the first half last week. But I would say the Cats win and beat the spread

Penn State by 15 over Oregon State. OSU was upset by Stanford but scored a lot of points. Game is at Penn State. Nittany Lions suspended 4 more players, one kicked off the team for good. All things being said, Penn State wins by more than 15 but barely more. Oregon State was supposed to be a pretty good team this year..this could be the upset of the week in terms of point spread

Thursday, August 28, 2008

Great Preview of the Big Ten season via the Chicago Tribune

Teddy Greenstein covers college football for the Chicago Tribune. He has been doing the individual team previews over the past few weeks and they've been pretty good..a couple were a little "iffy" in terms of sharing the possibilities for success of mid tier teams but overall good reads.

Today however Teddy and the Tribune did a great job in my opinion creating a pre-season guide. They covered a lot of the things I've talked about such as non conference schedule strength, question marks different teams have and more.

He put together predictions of how the Big Ten standings and overall win-loss records will be for each team (I'm just doing Big Ten conference records in a couple of weeks) and there was a decent article sharing how low the Big Ten has sunk in terms of the national media and fans around the country.

Earlier this week, Teddy was the first writer I've seen remind everyone that Michigan not only lost all their offensive players but their TOP 4 tacklers from last year. Makes you wonder how the UM defense is getting Top Ten ratings by certain media outlets?

I'd like to add that Scott Shafer was not the first choice of Rich Rodriquez and how much does anyone around here know about him and RichRod's defensive philosophy? Could work out great but rank them in the Top Ten nationally?

To check out the Tribune's coverage on the Big Ten click here

Wednesday, August 20, 2008

Predictions from the "experts" and media

At some point maybe at the end of the season we will compare how well the pre-season polls match up with the final BCS poll to see which publications offer the most accurate prognostication. Have you ever seen a publication rate itself in this manner? I have not.

Long time readers will remember that I in fact do come clean and share how well I predicted. Admittedly I have tended to make my predictions only for the Big Ten season not the entire schedule. Last year I made my conference selections BEFORE the first game of the entire season however I predicted only the Big Ten standings..I’ll explain why I am switching back to the old formula in a later post.

I took the main 5 pre-season polls, if you have another one I should include I will be happy to add it in an amended post, just comment below. I included a couple of new columns. First I used the average rating to predict conference placing. Note these are NOT my predictions. Secondly I wanted to show which schools had wider variances in rankings than others.

For 5 schools; Indiana, Minnesota, Purdue, Northwestern and Iowa there are only 2 data points as the other 3 polls only rate the top 40 or so schools based on votes for the Top 25. The variance of these schools therefore is limited.

The Delta for Ohio State is a whopping One but that isn’t much of a surprise. Wisconsin however is amazingly consistent among the pollsters. Is anyone else surprised at this lack of variance or more surprised by the average ranking?

By far Michigan has the biggest delta ranging from a 24th place by USA Today to a 54th by Sports Illustrated. I explain this by several factors: Michigan has a new coach and virtually a completely new set of offensive players. No one else has fewer returning starters on offense. Secondly it could be that after 20 years of often over ranking the Wolverines someone at SI finally said enough and trashed them this year. USA Today and Athlon are among the publications that always tend to give Michigan the benefit of the doubt.

Michigan State has a healthy variance as well which can be explained several ways. First my guess is some of the lower rankings are based on people not doing their homework and realizing the job the coaching staff at MSU has done. Second, a number of publications and voters have seen 3 decades of roller coaster Spartan teams (sometimes within the same game! And are leery of ranking this team too high this year.

Last comment. I threw Utah into this post to show how it’s not so crazy to think Michigan is the underdog in Week 1.


AP ESPN USA Today SI Athlon Conference Finish Delta
Illinois 20 22 19 23 16 3 7
Indiana NR NR NR 82 65 10 17
Iowa NR NR NR 31 38 7 7
Michigan 31 37 24 54 28 5 30
Michigan State 35 31 40 38 49 6 18
Minnesota NR NR NR 78 78 11 0
Northwestern NR NR NR 50 53 8 3
Ohio State 2 3 3 2 2 1 1
Penn State 22 20 22 22 23 4 3
Purdue NR NR NR 59 54 9 5
Wisconsin 13 12 12 10 12 2 3

Sunday, August 17, 2008

Are we in the Era of the Big One?

In the 1970s the Big Ten was known as the Big Two and the Little 8 due to the dominance of Michigan and Ohio State and actually this was true for much of the 80s and well even the 90s. However the addition of Penn State, Barry Alvarez coming to Wisconsin and Illinois, Purdue, Michigan State and even Northwestern caused the expression to be minimized.

However we may be entering or may have already entered a new era..the Big One and the Little Ten. Consider what Ohio State has accomplished in the past few years:

2005: Tied with Penn State for Big Ten Championship
2006: All alone, undefeated in Big Ten play
2007: All alone, undefeated in Big Ten play
2008: Ranked #2 in the Nation in pre-season and heavy favorites in the Big Ten

Winning a 3rd sole Big Ten title isn't quite enough to state the case for the Big One, although it comes close given the co-championship in 2005. But looking forward, on paper Ohio State might be able to extend its dominance to 5 or more Big Ten titles in a row.

Rival.com rankings of recruiting classes

2008: Ohio State ranks #4, next Big Ten team is Michigan at #10
2007: Ohio State ranks #15, only Michigan at #12 ranks ahead of them
2006: Ohio State is #12 with only Penn State ahead of them at #6
2005: Ohio State is #12 with Iowa #11 and Michigan number 6

Class of 2009 early ranking..Ohio State #1, Michigan #4 and Michigan State #10

On paper Michigan is the only team that is even close to the year in year out recruiting of the Buckeyes and it will take at least 2 years for Rich Rodriguez to stock his team with offensive players who can handle the completely new offense. Some of Michigan's classes of 2007 and 2006 have already left (Boren and Mallett among others).

But championships aren't won on paper that's why they play the games but when you combine talent with good coaching and stay healthy, Ohio State has a bright future moving into the '10s!

Sunday, July 27, 2008

New season, new Blog lay out

I switched to using Blogger because it's easier to add links to Youtube, Google ads (which help pay the bandwidth bills for the www.fansofthebig11.com website and other cool tools. You can visit last season's posts at the old site .

Football season is around the corner, and I am spending most of my free web time working on a complete upgrade to the site, new logo, new lay out, most importantly new content including updated eSchedules. This year you will be able to download all our schedules and databases without supplying an email address due to popular demand.

Enjoy the upcoming year...lot's of interesting changes in how the Big Ten stacks up